Toppers Pizza Madison West Customer Reviews

Toppers Pizza Madison West

7850 Mineral Point Rd
Madison, WI 53717
Toppers Pizza in Madison, WI
What are people talking about?
    119 review(s)
    5 star reviews
    4 star reviews
    3 star reviews
    2 star reviews
    1 star reviews
    High Score
    Low Score
    Toppers Pizza aims to be the best pizza company in the world by killing it on every detail of the customer experience. Our claim to fame comes in the form of Topperstix™, arguably the planet’s most addictively delicious cheesy breadstix. Our House Pizzas start with our fresh, made-from-scratch dough, smothered in real Wisconsin cheese and finished with outrageous toppings such as French fried onions, oven-roasted tomatoes, mac ‘n cheese and tater tots. Not to mention, we are open later than late and our delivery drivers run to keep your food hot!

    OpenTell™ Reviews

    My pizza was perfect! I love the online ordering because I can make sure my order us exactly right.
    I think his name was Travis who took my order as well as who was there when I picked it up. He confirmed my order verbally when I got there and made sure everything was correct. He was friendly and even though he was working by himself (besides the delivery drivers) and was quite busy with customers inside and also ones calling in, I never got a feeling that he was overwhelmed or unhappy and did not complain that he was the only one there! Pizza was good. Will definitely order again. I'm very familiar with Toppers as I ate at the one in Stevens Point about 15 years ago when I was in school and the pizza has improved since then! I do hope that this gets shared with Travis as he was courteous and friendly. This was my first time ordering from this Toppers and it won't be the last!
    Honestly, it would take much more than the $3.00 coupon I'll get from filling out this survey to get me to ever return to this Toppers. We were told our pizza would be ready at 5:07pm - we didn't get it until 40 minutes later. When we went in to pick it up, the guy who served us said he would start it right away and it would be ready in another 10 to 15 minutes. We left and came back 15 minutes later and he said, "I might have lied, I'll make it right now" - he STILL hadn't started our pizza 15 minutes after he told us he would. My mom went to pay for it (she didn't realize I had paid for it online) and he was going to just let her pay for it a second time instead of telling her it had already been paid for. Finally our pizza was brought out to us at 5:45pm. When we got it home, they weren't tall boys (even though I had paid $1/pizza to get them as tall boys) and we were missing one of the dipping sauces. As I started eating my slice, it was completely dough in the middle. I chose to go to Toppers because my parents were visiting from out of state and they don't have Toppers, so I thought it would be nice to try something they can't get at home. I wish I would have just gone to Papa Johns because at least then our pizza would have been all the way cooked and on time.
    Friendly and great recommendations from staff, accurate order and fast delivery. I could not be happier with the service this morning.
    The food was great. A little more smiles from staff can go a long way.
    6 weeks ago
    Our pizza was made without the spinach we had ordered. The person who made it apologized and offered it to us for free or to make us a new one we would have to wait for and pay full price for. We chose to take the free pizza. We also ordered cinna stix. I had a $3 off coupon from a survey but he would not take it in the store. This was the first time I've had a bad experience with Toppers. I hope the person who was working in the store making the pizza was just having a bad day and that he has good days in the future.
    After a long crazy day at work, I was looking forward to not having to cook dinner on a Friday night. I ordered online, the myza/stix/soda deal was a good value. Everything came super fast, looking great and tasting awesome. I have never had a bad experience with any of the delivery people and they never ever have forgotten any part of my order like other companies frequently do. Yay Toppers!
    If delivery will take longer than the original estimated time, it would be nice to know that it will take longer. It would also be nice to get an apology for the extra delivery time. Another suggestion is to offer more promotions on topperstix. I enjoyed the topperstix and would like to see more deals on them than pizza; smaller sized deals too. I am also confused about your free topperstix coupon if you like toppers pizza on facebook. I liked the page and didn't receive a coupon when told I would (???)
    The order taker on the phone was very good, very friendly and patient since I didn't know the menu. The delivery driver looked very uncomfortable and I don't remember him saying one word. Maybe it was his first night.